Estate Agent Lead Generation: How to Win More Instructions and Build Consistency

WalkAsk any estate agent what they want more of and you’ll hear the same answer every time: more leads. Whether you’re brand new or running a well-established agency, there’s always that drive for more appraisals, more instructions, and more opportunities. The challenge isn’t ambition, it’s building a reliable system that delivers consistent results instead of short bursts followed by dry spells.

The truth is, most agents only ever scratch the surface when it comes to lead generation. They might post the occasional property update on Facebook, send out a few leaflets when a property goes on the market, or run the odd email campaign. Those things work, but on their own, they won’t get you far. The top-performing agents are the ones who treat lead generation like a process, not a guessing game.

Why consistency matters more than creativity

A record month feels incredible in the moment. You’re buzzing, the phone is ringing, and it seems like you’ve cracked the code. But fast forward a week and suddenly it doesn’t feel like enough anymore. That’s human nature at play. We adapt so quickly to what feels “normal” that yesterday’s success becomes today’s baseline. Unless you put structure behind your marketing, you end up chasing peaks instead of building steady momentum.

That’s where consistency comes in. The agents who succeed long-term aren’t the ones who pull off flashy one-off campaigns. They’re the ones who commit to simple, repeatable actions. If your dream agency would post every day on social media, then your current agency needs to be posting every day. If your ideal agency would send out a market update email every month, then start doing exactly that. The gap between where you are and where you want to be is closed by repetition.

The hidden cost of lead generation

One of the biggest mistakes agents make is underestimating the cost of their marketing. On paper, a leaflet drop looks cheap. Two thousand leaflets printed for £100 sounds like a bargain. But what about the 20 hours it takes to deliver them? If you value your time at £50 an hour, that’s another £1,000 added to the cost. Suddenly, those “cheap” leaflets are costing £550 per instruction, or £1,100 per sale.

That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t do leaflet drops. It just means you need to measure them properly. Every marketing channel has a cost in both money and time. Once you understand that, you can start comparing results fairly and deciding what to scale up.

Expand, enhance, then innovate

When you’ve worked out what’s generating results, follow a simple three-step process. First, expand. Do more of what already works. If door knocking is effective, knock on more doors. If Facebook ads are bringing in appraisals, increase your budget slightly.

Second, enhance. Improve your approach so you get better results from the same effort. That could mean upgrading your property videos, sharpening your sales scripts, or using better targeting in your ads. Small tweaks can make a big difference.

Finally, innovate. Once you’ve maxed out the first two steps, then it’s time to try something new. Maybe that’s experimenting with TikTok ads, starting a local podcast, or running webinars for homeowners. But innovation should come last, not first.

As Jack from Agent Extra, a digital marketing lead generation specialist for estate agents, explains:

“The agents who generate the most leads don’t spread themselves thin chasing every new trend. They focus on doing the basics well, consistently, and only add new channels once their core lead generation engine is firing.”

Multiple touch points win instructions

One of the biggest misconceptions in estate agency is that a single piece of marketing wins a client. In reality, it’s usually the combination of touchpoints. A homeowner might have been following your videos for six months, liked your posts on Facebook, and then finally picked up the phone when your leaflet landed on their doormat. The leaflet got the credit, but the truth is, it was the whole mix that made the difference.

That’s why variety is so powerful. Deliver “just listed” and “just sold” letters in your patch. Post short, engaging videos about the local market. Run targeted Facebook or Google ads to homeowners in your area. Support local schools or community events. Host drop-in sessions at a coffee shop. Stay in touch with past clients. None of these methods on their own is a silver bullet, but together, consistently, they create brand recognition that makes you the obvious choice when someone decides to sell.

Measure, review, and raise the bar

The easiest way to stay on top of your marketing is to treat it like any other appointment. Schedule your activity into your diary and stick to it. If you say you’re going to post daily, then set it to repeat daily. If you’re sending a monthly email, block out time every month to get it done.

Review your results every six months. Compare what you’re actually doing to what your dream agency would be doing. Look at where you can expand, where you can enhance, and only then where you might innovate. Over time, the aim is to get closer to 100 percent consistency across your chosen activities.

And once you get there, raise the bar. If you’re posting once a day on social media, start posting twice. If you’re sending a market update every month, move it to fortnightly. Growth comes from pushing beyond what feels comfortable, not settling when things are ticking along.

Final thought

Lead generation doesn’t have to be complicated. In fact, the simpler and more structured you keep it, the better. Track your results, back your winners, and stay consistent. Do that, and you won’t just have more leads — you’ll have a predictable pipeline that gives you confidence, stability, and space to grow your business.

💡 Want to grow your estate agency?

At The Estate Agent Consultancy, we help self-employed agents win more instructions, charge higher fees, and grow faster.

📘 Get your FREE copy of Your First £100,000 Estate Agency book

🔗 You might also enjoy these blogs:

• How to Get Listings from Withdrawn Properties

• How to Find Listings by Leveraging Buyers in Your Local Area